Comparison Of Thermal Drying And Composting

In recent years, thermal drying and composting have become useful technologies for the preparation of class A biosolids. Let us examine three sludge-processing schemes, shown in Figure 9.4, to compare the heat consumption of these two technologies. Let the quantity of raw primary and thickened activated sludge be 800 m3/d with 4% dry solids.

Scheme 1

Scheme 2

Scheme 3

Figure 9.4 Sludge processing schemes.

Scheme 3

Figure 9.4 Sludge processing schemes.

Scheme 1

heat necessary for sludge digestion = (800 m3 /d)(106Mj/ m )

= 84,800 Mj/d heat obtained by sludge digestion = (800m3/d)(235Mj/m3)

= 188,000 Mj/d excess heat from sludge digestion = (800mVd)[(235-106)Mj/m3]

volume of dewatered sludge with 24% solides = (800m3/d)(

volume of thermally dried sludge with 90% solids = (800 m3/d)(

= 35.6mVd moisture to be evaporated for drying = (133 - 35.6)m3/d

= 97.4 m3/d heat required to evaporated moisture = (97.4m3/d)(1000kg/m3 )(3.9MJ/kg)

Utilization of the digester's excess heat (103,200 MJ/d) will reduce the energy consumption for thermal drying.

A heat exchanger following the thermal dryer can recover the heat required for sludge digestion, which is 84,800 MJ/d. Therefore, net heat required for thermal drying of sludge = (379,860 -103,200 + 84,800) Mj/d = 361,460 Mj/d

The process allows the reduction of 188,000 MJ/d of heat.

Scheme 2 The quantity of organics reduced during composting process averages about 25% , but for digested sludge, with the reduced quantity of organics, it can be just 10%. For primary sludge, the reduction is more than 45%, and for activated sludge it is about 30 to 35%. Let us assume that the reduction of organics during composting of the mixture of raw primary and activated sludge is 35%. Then the quantity of reduced organics is (28 kg/m3)(35%) = 9.8 kg/m3, which is (800 m3/d)(9.8 kg/m3) = 7840 kg/d.

heat released from composting = (7840kg/d)(21 MJ/kg)

Reduction of 1 kg of organics results in the removal of 5 kg of moisture. Therefore, moisture removed = (7840kg/d)(5kg/kg)

Scheme 3 The quantity of organics reduced during composting of digested sludge is 10%, which is (28 kg/m3)(40%)(10%) = 1.1 kg/m3, where 40% is the organics reduced in digestion.

organics reduced in composting = (800m3/d)(1.1kg/m3)

=880kg/d heat released during composting = (880kg/d)(21 MJ/kg)

= 18,480 MJ/d excess heat from sludge digestion = 103,200 MJ/d (see Scheme 1) total heat obtained = (18,480 +103,200) MJ/d = 121,680 MJ/d mositure evaporated from sludge = (880kg/d)(5kg/kg)+ 103,200MJ/d

= 30,900 kg/d (30.9m3/d) Table 9.1 compares energy use in the three process schemes.

TABLE 9.1 Comparison of Energy Use (MJ/d)

Scheme 2

Scheme 3

Scheme 1

(Raw Sludge

(Digested Sludge


(Thermal Drying)



Heat required for process


Heat reduced


Heat obtained



Organic Gardeners Composting

Organic Gardeners Composting

Have you always wanted to grow your own vegetables but didn't know what to do? Here are the best tips on how to become a true and envied organic gardner.

Get My Free Ebook

Post a comment